The Question (ID Number 616)...
...and the response:If you get no exercise, smoke three packs a day. and have high blood pressure and high cholesterol, a doctor can tell you that you're working up to a heart attack. Is he "telling you how to live"? No, he's just pointing out the consequences of your lifestyle. If, on the basis of what he says, you decide to quit smoking, exercise regularly, and change your diet, does that make him a prophet? I've said that if there are still people here in 200 years, they won't be living the way we do, because if people go on living the way we do, there won't BE any people here in 200 years. That doesn't make me a prophet any more than the doctor is a prophet. I nowhere tell anyone how to live. In fact, I say very specifically, again and again, that there is NO ONE RIGHT WAY for people to live. So how could I be telling people how to live? Besides all this, a prophet is one who speaks with divine authority. You're to believe what he says, because it comes from God. By contrast, I don't claim to speak with divine authority, and I definitely don't want anyone to "believe" me. If you have doubts about what I say, don't get down on your knees and pray for faith. Go to the library and check it out.
Go Back OR return to the Questions & Answers OR Browse to the Next Question
| Site design and content © 2019, Daniel Quinn|