I’ve read Ishmael and The Story of B. Your thinking seems sound and well thought out. You have proved through logical reasoning that God as Christians know him does not exist.

On the other hand, C.S. Lewis proved in much the same fashion in Mere Christianity that God does very much exist.

Have you read his book? Any response?

I don’t consider that I’ve “proved through logical reasoning that God as Christians know him does not exist.”

I haven’t read C.S. Lewis’s “proof,” but there are dozens of such “proofs,” which all work fine—provided that you accept the premises on which the proof is based. As far as I’m concerned, neither the existence nor the nonexistence of God can be established (and writing a “proof” doesn’t accomplish that).

ID: 716
posted:
updated: 24 Jun 2005