I work at a small, conservative high school, and am trying to organize a new course for next year. The course I have in mind is designed to teach students about ecology and our country’s national heritage in wilderness areas and natural resources. We would like to use Ishmael as one of the texts to challenge students’ concepts of nature. Our school administration is very concerned about this text. shocked and appalled that a district would allow such texts as Mythology, Of Mice and Men, To Kill a Mockingbird, to be used and still consider censoring a text like Ishmael. I have gone through the Ishmael website and read your response that, “Christianity is meaningful to our culture because it CONDEMNS the selfish, greedy, destructive lifestyle” of the takers. Can you offer any other response to help get your text approved?

Ishmael says he knows of no biblical scholar who interprets the Genesis stories of the Fall and Cain and Abel the way he does. Is it “established” that these stories originated among Semitic witnesses to these events, or did you arrive at this hypothesis by deduction? I ask not because I find the explanation unpalatable by any means but, rather to find out if there are any fairly digestible books on that subject which you could recommend.

I wonder if you can elaborate on the idea in My Ishmael of the similarities between cult and tribal mentality. I agree that people who join cults are looking for a sort of tribal fulfillment for which we all may be looking. I can also see your reasoning in asserting that the word ‘cult’ has bad connotations in our culture and that we are predisposed to believe that cult leaders are crazy. However, I believe there is a psychological control element to cult behavior that I don’t imagine is present in tribal behavior. I know that often people involved in a cult want to leave and can’t which also doesn’t translate to the dynamic within a tribe, in my opinion. Also, I don’t think the self-destructive aspect of cults translates to tribal thinking. I can’t imagine a tribe destroying itself because of perceived threats from other tribes. I guess what I’m saying is that I think cults are bad. I can see that the desire to join one is a symptom of our non-tribal society and I think this is a valid point. The rest of the argument in My Ishmael is a bit of a stretch for me.

Go to Top